Was $38,000 for 7 Nights at Aman New York Worth It?
The Aman New York is not just a hotel—it is a 20,000-square-foot spa with a 230-foot indoor pool and a hotel attached. When Aman announced it was opening in New York, the luxury travel world held its breath. Aman had never done a city hotel before. The brand known for remote resort sanctuaries in Southeast Asia was opening on Fifth Avenue.
I spent 7 nights and $38,000 finding out whether they pulled it off. This is the honest truth.
What Are the Rooms Like?
The Aman New York has 83 rooms and suites, making it one of the least dense luxury hotels in Manhattan. The entry-level room is 75 square meters—enormous by New York standards, where a typical luxury hotel room is 30-40 square meters.
| Category | Size | Rate/Night | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fifth Avenue Suite | 75 sqm | $3,800 | Standard luxury, exceptional for NYC |
| Aman Suite | 100 sqm | $6,000 | Separate living room, larger |
| Corner Suite | 130 sqm | $8,500 | Panoramic views of Fifth Ave |
The design is classic Aman: stone, wood, and water. A 75 cm-deep Japanese soaking tub sits in the bathroom. The bed is custom-made with Aman linens. There is no art on the walls—Aman believes the view and the architecture are the art.
What About the Spa and Pool?
The spa is the Aman New York's defining feature. The 230-foot indoor pool is the longest hotel pool in New York. The 20,000 sq ft spa includes a hammam, cold plunge pool, steam rooms, and a yoga studio.
The pool alone justifies the stay. Swimming 230 feet through candlelit tunnels under a vaulted stone ceiling is an experience no other New York hotel offers.
Final Verdict
Strengths:
- Largest standard rooms in NYC
- 230-foot indoor pool (best in NYC)
- 25,000 sq ft spa
- Exceptional Japanese-inspired service
- Fifth Avenue location
Weaknesses:
- $3,800/night is extremely expensive
- Limited dining options (2 venues)
- Can feel quiet (lack of energy)
Rating: 9.5/10 Best for: The ultimate luxury NYC experience. Spa enthusiasts. travelers who value space and serenity. Not for: Budget-conscious travelers. Those seeking vibrant hotel energy.
Last updated: June 2025. Prices are subject to change. Verify current rates directly with the hotel before booking.